Best Stocking Fillers Gifts

We have aggregated the recommendations for stocking fillers from trusted experts that have been featured by leading publishers like the New York Times, Washington Post, The Guardian and many others.
All stocking fillers listed on CriticPick have a customer review rating of a minimum of 4.0 out of 5 stars. The ratings you see on our website are aggregated from different sources, so you know you always buy an awesome stocking filler gift.
Just imagine… Christmas time, friends and families in your home, delightful laughter and giggles of children with the Christmas tree and presents in the backdrop. Won’t the stockings be incomplete without the stocking fillers for all the little visitors to your house?
If you want to buy the best and interesting stocking fillers, you do not need to look out any further than the place from where you can get all the presents that have been rated high by reputed critics and publications.
The wide assorted range of stocking fillers will help you become the Secret Santa or the perfect host at your home Christmas party and delighting your tiny guests. We also have the quirkiest collection of stocking fillers that will help you to go offbeat and have fun along with the kids… after all, why should kids have all the fun?
Whether you're purchasing the stocking fillers for children, your spouse, partner, sibling, or parents, you can choose from the broad array of amusing stocking fillers that will leave them delighted and surprised all the way through the New Year.

Show only:

Sort by:

Stocking Fillers
4.6 Winsor Newton Cotman Box

Winsor & Newton Cotman Water Colour Paint Sketchers’ Pocket Box


“If she’s looking for a new hobby, watercolor painting is a non-intimidating medium to throw yourself into.”

4.3 William Morris Ecoffee Cup

William Morris Reusable Eco Friendly Takeaway Coffee Cup


The rather special reusable William Morris Ecoffee cup (made from bamboo fibres) makes for an excellent gift for design-and-coffee loving mums.”

4.8 Strata Cups Camera Coffee Mug

Strata Cups Camera Lens Coffee Mug


Add a shot of fun to a photographer’s coffee with this realistic travel lens mug, designed to look and feel like a real camera lens.”

4.7 Herbivore Detox Bath Salts

Herbivore Botanicals Detox Bath Salts

Harpers Bazaar

“Doesn’t your mom deserve some pampering? A soak with these skin-loving clay and eucalyptus infused bath salts will leave her relaxed and refreshed.”

4.6 The Neighborgoods Towels

The Neighborgoods Kitchen Flour Sack Towel

Washington Post

“Punny, two-pocket aprons in a sturdy poly-cotton blend and flour sack cotton dish towels with seasonal and practical prints are useful and cute, while a button four-pack with clever graphics makes the perfect stocking-stuffer.”

Featured in The Washington Post’s 2017 Best Gift Guide.

4.4 Lamy Fountain Pen

Lamy Safari Fountain Pen

New York Times

“Most fountain pens are expensive, flowery or require special ink. But the Lamy Safari is simple, easy to use and perfect for anyone who still loves setting pen to paper.”

Featured in New York Times’ 2017 Gift Guide.